Sag Harbor Restaurants Near The Inn

Virtually every street in Sag Harbor is crowded with restaurants. Choose from fabulous seafood to tasty Italian, Mexican, Japanese, Cajun, Indian and American cuisine. Following is a partial list of local eateries.

Bay Burger

1742 Sag Harbor Tpke, Sag Harbor
A modern take on the road-side burger joint. Menu features Burgers, Grilled Cheeses, Hot Dogs, Veggie Burgers and Ice Cream.

Cappelletti Italian Grill

3284 Noyac Road, Sag Harbor
Restaurant, Take-Out, Pizza, Catering.

Conca D'Oro Pizzeria Restaurant

Main Street, Sag Harbor
Pizza, heroes & Italian dishes.

The Corner Bar

1 Main Street, Sag Harbor
View of the bay, directly across from Long Wharf & The Windmill. Featuring fresh local seafood, hearty sandwiches, burgers & steaks.

Il Capuccino Ristorante

Madison Street, Sag Harbor
Serving the best in Northern Italian Cuisine. This is a local favorite with excellent wines and the best garlic knots. Great food, Great atmosphere! Open all year.

Dockside Bar & Grill

26 Bay St , Sag Harbor
With a million-dollar view of the yacht basin, this grill is located at the American Legion. Enjoy great outdoor seating, seafood, sandwiches and complete entrees.

La Superica Restaurant

Main Street and Long Island Avenue (at the Flag Pole), Sag Harbor
Located at the foot of the Sag Harbor-North Haven bridge. Authentic, fresh Mexican food with a beautiful water view!

Murph's Back Street Tavern

64 Division Street, Sag Harbor
Established in 1976, Murph's is the last of the old "Gin Mills" left in Sag Harbor. Laid back Old Pub charm. The people are local and the juke box serves up the best old hits!

New Paradise Café

126 Main Street, Sag Harbor
Comfortable, casual dining with a lively bar scene. Bar menu, Patio dining. Grilled fish, crab cakes, lobster salad, roasted duck, steaks.


23 Main Street, Sag Harbor
Highest Zagat rating in the Hamptons for a Japanese restaurant and Sushi Bar. Sit back and relax in the Sake Lounge with a wide array of sake and martinis to choose from.

Tutto Il Giorno

6 Bay Street, PO Box 1816, Sag Harbor
Exceptional dining with a view of the Harbor, opposite Marine Park. Featuring inspired New Italian cuisine.